Cabinet Refinishing vs. Full Replacement

When it’s time to update your kitchen or bathroom, few decisions are as impactful as choosing how to handle your cabinets. They’re often the room’s focal point, setting the tone for the entire space. So, the question is: do you go with a complete cabinet replacement or opt for refinishing? Below, we break down the key factors to help you make the best decision for your home.

Budget

Refinishing: One of the biggest draws of cabinet refinishing is the cost-effectiveness. Refinishing can be up to 60-70% less expensive than replacing your cabinets entirely, making it an excellent option for homeowners on a budget. With refinishing, you keep your existing cabinet frames, so you’re only paying for the labor and materials needed to strip, sand , and paint your cabinets.

New Cabinets: Installing new cabinets is a significant investment. The total cost will depend on your material choices, cabinet layout, and customizations. However, this approach allows for total freedom in terms of layout and design, which may be worth the cost for some homeowners. Keep in mind that a layout change typically also requires a flooring update.

Time

Refinishing: This process is considerably faster. The job can often be completed in a couple of appointments, depending on the size of your kitchen and the complexity of the finish. Refinishing minimizes downtime and allows you to enjoy your new kitchen or bathroom sooner.

New Cabinets: Installing new cabinets takes more time. The old cabinets need to be removed, and new ones need to be installed, which can involve structural adjustments, new countertop installations, flooring replacement, and even plumbing or electrical work. This process may take several weeks.

Environmental Impact

Refinishing: Refinishing cabinets is an eco-friendly choice. By using your existing cabinetry, you’re reducing waste and the resources needed to produce new cabinets. Eco-conscious homeowners often choose this option to cut down on material waste and the carbon footprint associated with manufacturing and transporting new cabinetry.

New Cabinets: If you’re set on replacing, consider cabinets made from sustainable materials or low-VOC finishes. Some companies specialize in environmentally friendly cabinets that use recycled materials and non-toxic glues. However, even with these options, replacing cabinets generally has a larger environmental footprint than refinishing.

Customization and Style

Refinishing: If you’re happy with the existing layout of your kitchen and the quality of your cabinets, refinishing offers a huge range of customization in terms of color. You can go from traditional wood tones to sleek, modern colors with just a few coats of paint. However, you’re limited to the structure of your current cabinetry.

New Cabinets: New cabinets allow complete control over the look and feel of your space. You can choose from endless cabinet styles, finishes, and layouts. If you want open shelving, taller cabinets, or additional storage solutions, installing new cabinets is likely the best route.

Cabinet Condition

Refinishing: For cabinets that are still structurally sound but simply look worn or outdated, refinishing is a great option. If you’re dealing with minor scratches, dents, or faded finishes, a new coat of paint or stain can give them new life. But if your cabinets have significant water damage, mold, or are made of low-quality materials, refinishing may not be a good option. Consider refacing (a.k.a. redooring) or complete replacement instead.

New Cabinets: As mentioned above, new cabinets are often necessary when the existing ones are damaged beyond repair. Mold, extensive water damage, or poor quality materials that have degraded over time generally aren’t suitable for refinishing. In such cases, investing in new, high-quality doors and drawer-fronts, or complete cabinet replacement will pay off in the long run.

Resale Value

Refinishing: Updating cabinets with a fresh finish can significantly improve the look of your kitchen, making it more appealing to potential buyers. Many homebuyers are attracted to well-maintained, attractive kitchens, and a quality refinish may boost market value without the high cost of replacement.

New Cabinets: High-end, custom cabinets can increase the resale value of your home, especially if you’re in a competitive real estate market. If a kitchen renovation aligns with the market expectations in your area, new cabinets may give you a good return on investment.

Which Should You Choose?

• Go for Refinishing if: You want a budget-friendly, quick, and eco-friendly upgrade, and your cabinets are in good shape.

• Opt for New Cabinets if: You need a structural overhaul, want a layout change, or your cabinets are beyond repair.

  
  

Updating your cabinets can dramatically improve your space. Whether you choose refinishing or new cabinets, the end result should be a beautiful, functional, and stylish kitchen that meets your needs for years to come. Contact us at Urban Fresh Services for more information or click here for a free virtual quote!

We look forward to hearing from you!